<?xml version="1.0"?>
<!DOCTYPE ArticleSet PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD PubMed 2.0//EN" "http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query/static/PubMed.dtd">
<ArticleSet>
  <Article>
    <Journal>
      <PublisherName>Barw</PublisherName>
      <JournalTitle>Barw Medical Journal</JournalTitle>
      <Issn>2960-1959</Issn>
      <PubDate PubStatus="epublish">
        <Year>2024</Year>
        <Month>08</Month>
        <Day>02</Day>
      </PubDate>
    </Journal>
    <ArticleTitle>Role of ChatGPT and Gemini in the Urology Field: A Case-Based Study</ArticleTitle>
    <ELocationID EIdType="doi">10.58742/bmj.v2i3.116</ELocationID>
    <Language>eng</Language>
    <AuthorList>
      <Author>
        <FirstName EmptyYN="Y"/>
        <LastName>Rawa Bapir</LastName>
        <Affiliation>Department of Urology, Sulaimani Surgical Teaching Hospital, Sulaymaniyah, Iraq . rawa.ali@gmail.com</Affiliation>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName EmptyYN="Y"/>
        <LastName>Ahmed Mohammed Abdalqadir</LastName>
        <Affiliation>Department of Urology, Sulaimani Surgical Teaching Hospital, Sulaymaniyah, Iraq . ahmed.abdalqadir@gmail.com</Affiliation>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName EmptyYN="Y"/>
        <LastName>Kamran Hassan Bhatti</LastName>
        <Affiliation>Urology Department, Hamad Medical Corporation, Al Khor Hospital, Qatar. kamibhatti92@gmail.com</Affiliation>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName EmptyYN="Y"/>
        <LastName>Nadeem Sohail</LastName>
        <Affiliation>Urology Department, Hamad Medical Corporation, Al Khor Hospital, Qatar. nadeem.Sohail@gmail.com</Affiliation>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName EmptyYN="Y"/>
        <LastName>Bryar Othman Muhammed</LastName>
        <Affiliation>Smart Health Tower (Raparin Branch), Karux Street, Rania, Iraq. bryar.muhammed@gmail.com</Affiliation>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName EmptyYN="Y"/>
        <LastName>Ameer M. Salih</LastName>
        <Affiliation>Civil Engineering Department, College of Engineering, University of Sulaimani, Sulaymaniyah, Iraq. ameer.salih@univsul.edu.iq</Affiliation>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName EmptyYN="Y"/>
        <LastName>Hunzalah Hassan Bhatti</LastName>
        <Affiliation>College of Engineering, Department of Computer Science, University of Qatar, Doha, Qatar. Hunzalah.bhatti@gmail.com</Affiliation>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName>Hawbash</FirstName>
        <LastName>Rahim</LastName>
        <Affiliation>Department of Medical Laboratory Science, College of Health Sciences, University of Human Development, Sulaimani, Iraq. hawbash.kurdish@yahoo.com</Affiliation>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName EmptyYN="Y"/>
        <LastName>Jihad Ibrahim Hama</LastName>
        <Affiliation>Research Center, University of Halabja, Halabja, Iraq. jihad.hama@gmail.com</Affiliation>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName EmptyYN="Y"/>
        <LastName>Hemin S. Mohammed</LastName>
        <Affiliation>Smart Health Tower, Madam Mitterrand Street, Sulaymaniyah, Iraq. hemn.ali@gmail.com</Affiliation>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName EmptyYN="Y"/>
        <LastName>Muhammed Bag A. Ali</LastName>
        <Affiliation>Smart Health Tower (Raparin Branch), Karux Street, Rania, Iraq. muhammed.ali@gmail.com</Affiliation>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName EmptyYN="Y"/>
        <LastName>Sabah Jalal Hasan</LastName>
        <Affiliation>Smart Health Tower, Madam Mitterrand, Sulaymaniyah, Iraq. sabah.jalal@gmail.com</Affiliation>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName EmptyYN="Y"/>
        <LastName>Ismaeel Aghaways</LastName>
        <Affiliation>College of Medicine, University of Sulaimani, Madam Mitterrand Street, Sulaymaniyah, Iraq. ismael.abdullah@gmail.com</Affiliation>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName EmptyYN="Y"/>
        <LastName>Yousif M. Mahmood</LastName>
        <Affiliation>Smart Health Tower, Madam Mitterrand Street, Sulaymaniyah, Iraq. yousuf.smarthealth@gmail.com</Affiliation>
      </Author>
      <Author>
        <FirstName EmptyYN="Y"/>
        <LastName>Hussein M. Hamasalih</LastName>
        <Affiliation>Smart Health Tower, Madam Mitterrand Street, Sulaymaniyah, Iraq. hussein.hama@gmail.com</Affiliation>
      </Author>
    </AuthorList>
    <History>
      <PubDate PubStatus="received">
        <Year>2024</Year>
        <Month>07</Month>
        <Day>07</Day>
      </PubDate>
    </History>
    <Abstract>
Introduction


The healthcare sector is witnessing a transformation with the advent of artificial intelligence (AI), exemplified by ChatGPT and Gemini AI. These AI systems emulate human conversation and provide accurate medical responses. This study explores their integration into medical decision-making in the urology field.


Methods


The study presented a collection of 20 medical case scenarios, carefully crafted and revised by a team of authors in the field of urology. Each case was presented to ChatGPT and Gemini in September of 2023, and their responses were recorded and analyzed.


Results


Both AI tools displayed varying accuracy in diagnoses and management recommendations. ChatGPT failed in identifying congenital penile curvature, while Gemini succeeded. Conversely, ChatGPT excelled in recommending a management plan for renal artery aneurysms. Gemini outperformed in explaining iodinated contrast material toxicity. Both struggled with a bladder prolapse prevention question.


Conclusion


AI integration in urology is promising but has limitations. AI provides valuable insights but cannot replace human expertise. Research is vital to improve AI's role in urology. Clinicians should view AI suggestions as supplements to their judgment, fostering collaborative healthcare decisions.
</Abstract>
  </Article>
</ArticleSet>
